Case Overview
This action arises from events at 889 Francisco Street, Los Angeles, within the Metropolis I condominium community. Plaintiff Kevin Moda, a tenant of Unit 801, alleges a coordinated campaign of tenant harassment, an unlawful lockout, and privacy violations orchestrated by an unlicensed property manager and HOA personnel who lacked authority to act.
Filed July 8, 2025 in Los Angeles County Superior Court, this case has proceeded through a temporary restraining order, a preliminary injunction (granted September 4, 2025), multiple anti-SLAPP motions, judicial-assignment challenges, and cross-claims.
Key Alleged Facts
The following facts are drawn from Plaintiff's pleadings and declarations. They are contested by the defendants.
The Unlicensed Property Manager
Joshua Cieszynski was terminated by Action Property Management, Inc. on February 29, 2024, as confirmed by a sworn declaration from Action's Chief Operating Officer, Matthew Davidson. Cieszynski then formed Metro Property Management, LLC — a single-member LLC categorically incapable of holding a California DRE broker's license — and continued managing the Metropolis I building as if nothing had changed. A DRE license search shows no broker license for either Cieszynski or Metro Property Management, LLC.
The HOA Contract & Pariser's Role
HOA Board President Oleg Pariser executed the property management agreement with Metro Property Management, LLC on February 28, 2024. Plaintiff contends Pariser signed unilaterally, without a board vote or competitive bidding required by the CC&Rs. A forensic review of the contract (Exhibit 1 to the Pariser Declaration) revealed that Page 17 still contained the name "Action Property Management, Inc." in its pricing clause — indicating the contract was plagiarized from a competitor's template. Plaintiff alleges Pariser did not read the contract before signing.
The Fabrication Timeline
On June 2, 2025, staff member Frank Marenco sent an email stating only that he "smelled" an odor in the sauna. Twenty-eight days later, a Three-Day Notice to Quit — drafted by Defendant Aghazarian's counsel — escalated this to a claim that Plaintiff was "witnessed by two people urinating in public," added accusations of voyeurism, and demanded vacation within three days.
The Lockout
On July 2, 2025, Cieszynski issued a "Notice of Decision" revoking Plaintiff's key fobs and all building access. On July 17, 2025, a physical lockout of Unit 801 was executed. The court entered a Temporary Restraining Order on July 24, 2025 and a Preliminary Injunction on September 4, 2025 (Judge Chalfant, Dept. 85), ordering that Plaintiff's access be restored and maintained.
Current Procedural Status
| Matter | Status |
|---|---|
| Preliminary Injunction (access to Unit 801) | In Effect Granted Sept. 4, 2025 |
| Anti-SLAPP Motion (Cieszynski & Metro Property Management) | Denied June 15, 2026 — Hon. Cherol J. Nellon, Dept. 300 |
| Motion for Summary Adjudication (Cieszynski) | Filed |
| Motion for Summary Adjudication (Pariser) | Filed |